Final Words

Overall, we have nothing but good things to say about Beyond TV 3. SnapStream has put a lot of thought into the multimedia experience, though there still is some fine-tuning that needs to be done (i.e. double listing TV shows).

The live TV information panels have more of a love-it or hate-it scheme. We have mixed opinions. The berth of information is helpful, but not all of it is necessary, such as the incredibly large live TV and recording icon in the upper left hand corner. Our own recommendation would be to follow Microsoft's example with Windows XP Media Center 2004. The information panel there is a separate page, with a small information panel for immediate viewing. What SnapStream is implementing now is a bit obtrusive in our opinion, though helpful.

Beyond TV 3 separates itself from the rest of the bunch with its web server capabilities and web admin interface. The fact that you can control recordings while away from home is extremely helpful, and so is the ability to stream TV over the network locally, as well as over the internet.

 



Click to enlarge.

 



Click to enlarge.


Perhaps most interesting is that Beyond TV 3 is Pocket PC friendly. Though, we won't be using this capability much, it is probably worth investigating it for those TV buffs who own Pocket PC phones. In theory, you can watch streaming TV from your home on your PDA anywhere. We were comfortably watching TV and videos on our Dell X5 (using our awesome D-Link 802.11b/802.11g network) without any configuration woes.




Click to enlarge.


SnapStream isn't making this a cheap software title: $69.99 for CD-ROM and $59.99 for download, so this isn't a chump-change purchase. But if you are looking for a more solid TV/media server, this is the title to buy. SnapStream is hyping up their entrance into the consumer market: Best Buy, CompUSA, etc., which seems to be adding credence to their software title. With a few more improvements, SnapStream will easily have the trump multimedia title on their hands. It is arguably the best on the market, at the moment.

Beyond TV 3 already beats InterVideo's Home Theater hands down, which is why Asus probably should have taken a look at SnapStream instead. MSI is working on some sort of a media version of their MegaPC. We hope that they are considering their choice for software as much as they are for their hardware design. And if you own a Personal Cinema card and aren't willing to switch to ATI's All-in-Wonder line for their software benefit, Beyond TV 3 may be something right up your alley, since it looks like Forceware Multimedia is still going to take a while. For those with WinTV cards, this might be something worth considering too.

Web Admin – A Welcome Relief (continued)
Comments Locked

17 Comments

View All Comments

  • batorok - Thursday, May 13, 2004 - link

    as a Sagetv user I'm pretty miffed they didn't compare the two. Sagetv 2.0 has a really nice new interface, handles multimedia (pics, mp3z, movies, dvds including vob files) pretty well, has multituner support, and better image quality of viewed tv (I demoed both before buying sage). Since tv is what it's all about, the picture quality is what's important to me.
  • reboos - Thursday, May 13, 2004 - link

    MythTv is very nice.
  • mcveigh - Wednesday, May 12, 2004 - link

    good question crazy_vag

    I don't think snapstream supports HD capture cards
  • crazy_vag - Wednesday, May 12, 2004 - link

    When will I be able to record Soprano's in HDTV on HTPC???
  • mcveigh - Wednesday, May 12, 2004 - link

    I think you should consider comparing it to tivo/replay as I think this is more what it is aimed at replacing.

    also I would like to see more info about multile tuners.

    how about a shoot out of personal video software in the future?

    SnapStream vs. sage TV vs. windows MCE vs. ????
  • Jeff7181 - Wednesday, May 12, 2004 - link

    Wonderful review. Looks like a very robust piece of software. If I was in the market to build a HTPC I'd probably buy it. From what I see, I like the information windows... they have a little bit too much info, but at least they're transparent so you can still see the show... unlike Comcast the last time I paid for digital cable.
  • llamas - Wednesday, May 12, 2004 - link

    Are you considering a review of SageTV 2.0 (just released)? It would interesting to hear how it compares with BTV3. SageTV supports multiple tuners, and has client software with the same interface as the server.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now